Who Is An Indian: Testy Panel Exchange Ends Peacefully

By STU WOO
The UNITY News

Kenneth Cooper felt he and his fellow Freedmen were left out.

Last March, the Cherokee Nation voted to define requirements for citizenship. Now, only ancestors of Native Americans registered under the Dawes Commission — a century-old federal government census of Native Americans — can become citizens.

But Cooper felt that was a racially tinged snub to the Freedmen, ancestors of the tribe’s former African slaves. So when Cherokee Nation Principal Chief Chad Smith said Friday at a UNITY forum that race didn’t matter under the new requirements, Cooper stepped up to the microphone during the question-and-answer session.

“The first thing that you said … made me really angry,” said Cooper, who identifies as a Cherokee Freedman. The two then exchanged testy comments for the next five minutes.

In March 2007, 77 percent of Cherokee Nation citizens voted to approve a constitutional amendment allowing only those who have a Cherokee, Delaware or Shawnee ancestor listed on the Dawes Commission rolls. The commission took a census of Native Americans, taken from 1898 to 1907, to divest the Nation of its lands and allot them to individual citizens. The 2007 amendment overturned a 2006 Tribal Court ruling allowing non-Indian descendants of Freedmen and intermarried whites to become citizens.

Cooper said he found the amendment unjust, especially given that some of the tribe’s wealth came from slave work. He found the new restrictions unfair to Freedmen who had Cherokee blood because “there was no effort by the Dawes Commission (the federal census project) to find out if the Freedman had blood.”

Smith said that there were some Freedmen with Cherokee blood who were registered by the Dawes Commission, but Cooper said those were by far in the minority.

“The federal government provided due process,” Smith responded. “We cannot go back and second-guess that process. I cannot – perhaps you can.”

Friday’s forum, titled “Who is an Indian? Your Guide to Covering Native Americans,” was presented by the Native American Journalists Association.

Afterward, Cooper and Smith chatted outside the meeting room. The two had never met, though Smith was familiar with Cooper’s Louisiana Weekly column about the constitutional amendment last year. The meeting was amiable, both said, and Smith invited Cooper to discuss the topic with him in Cherokee Nation.

Both Cooper and Smith said they were glad to meet each other. Cooper said he would accept the offer to meet in Oklahoma as soon as his schedule allows.

Afterward, Cooper seemed to regret the surly nature of their question-and-answer session exchange, especially if he came off as an “angry black man,” Cooper said, smiling.

[del.icio.us] [Digg] [Facebook] [MySpace] [Newsvine] [StumbleUpon]

topic: Current Events
tags: , ,

One Response to “Who Is An Indian: Testy Panel Exchange Ends Peacefully”

  1. Arturo de Ablo Says:

    Talking is the key. It was disappointing that a similar type joint-meeting between the Cherokee Nation and the CBC last year ended after racism cries erupted. With more “after-meetings” like the one between the Chief and Cooper, perhaps the wall that divides the two sides can slowly be chipped away.

Leave a Reply

Map Your Chicago

Related Coverage of Current Events

Print Edition

Overcoming: One Reporter’s Story Of Controlling Anorexia
Although I am stable and I no longer starve myself, anorexia will always be a part of me.
Who Is An Indian: Testy Panel Exchange Ends Peacefully
Kenneth Cooper felt he and his fellow Freedmen were left out.
Cherokee Chief Works To Rebuild Nation
He was named “Ugista,” which means “Corntassal,” by his grandma. He comes from a strong family line that fought to hold onto tribal traditions and land.
Web Site Offers Demographic Data On Minority Kids, Families
State-level data about children and families in five of the largest racial groups are now publicly accessible on the Web.
After Katrina, Actor Rebuilds Homes, Lives
For Wendell Pierce, the devastation to his hometown of New Orleans was more memorable than any role he has played.

UNITY News Radio

Foosball for Learning
In Chicago, more than seventy artists are trying to generate a dialogue through an exhibit called “A Declaration of Immigration.” One interactive installation approaches the issue through a one-of-a-kind tabletop foosball game. Reporter Diane Lee has more.
 
 Standard Podcast [4:42m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download (452)
Green Alleys
A few years ago the mayor of Chicago issued a challenge. He urged every city department to become more eco-friendly. (In English and En Espanol.)
 
 Standard Podcast [3:12m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download (413)

 
 Standard Podcast [3:49m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download (2408)
Slow Economy Doesn’t Slow Fashion Sales
Unity News reporter Martha Flores reports that a rough economy doesn’t seem to be hurting the city’s fashion industry.
 
 Standard Podcast [2:05m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download (1382)
Leaving the Rez
Eighteen-year-old Povi Lomayaoma has lived on a Hopi reservation in Arizona her entire life. In two months, she’s leaving to go to college in Colorado to study journalism. She says she’ll miss many of her clan’s traditions.
 
 Standard Podcast [4:15m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download (208)
Senegalese President Arrives
Senegalese President Abdouloya Wade is making good on a year-long promise to address American journalists of color. A delegation from Unity: Journalists of Color met the visiting head of state at Chicago’s O’Hare airport Wednesday morning. Reporter Kristin Lee was there.
 
 Standard Podcast [2:12m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download (217)

Video Gallery

Online Exclusives

Obama Addresses UNITY as Convention Draws to a Close
Sen. Barack Obama addressed thousands of journalists at a live forum on the final day of the UNITY convention in his first appearance since returning to the U.S. after a spending a week overseas.
Emotions Flare During NAJA Panel
Debate over American Indian citizenship dominated a panel about Native American identity at the UNITY Convention on Friday.
Actor Offers Student Journalist Refreshing Reminder
I wasn’t prepared for the impact "The Wire" actor Wendell Pierce would have on me as a journalist.

Blog

President of Senegal:There Are Too Many Journalists
Senegal President Abdoulaye Wade told a dozen American journalists today that “there are too many papers in Senegal, too many journalists.”
Actor Offers Student Journalist Refreshing Reminder
I wasn’t prepared for the impact "The Wire" actor Wendell Pierce would have on me as a journalist.